Responsability for Sirius's Death

[udder_pen_dragon]

No: HPFGUIDX 84601

Hi All
I read a lot about who is believed to be responsible for Sirisus dieing. Of course the blame is shared is shared, I have compiled a list of the usual suspects and some mabee not so usual. I have put them in what I believe to be ranking order.
Please let me know what you think
1) Voldemort  :  Obviously
2) Bellatrix Lestrange  :  she fired the shot
3) Kretcher  :  If he had done his job and brought Sirius to talk to Harry, end of problem.
4) Sevrus Snape  :  for IMO not even attempting to teach Harry Occlumency. If you want to teach a 15 year old, to play Tennis you don't hire Rudedski and Phillipousis (excuse the spelling for bot of those) to serve aces at him in the hope that he might learn something.
5)  Dumbledore  :  For the same reason he blames himself OOTP UK starting page728
 
I don't blame Harry at all. He is only 15and there are adults(?) around him who are supposed to protect him and not, as in the case of Snape, to use him as a target for their own spite. 
 
Udder Pendragon
 
 
 
 



---------------------------------
Want to chat instantly with your online friends? Get the FREE Yahoo!Messenger

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]