[HPforGrownups] Re: Lexicon Contmaination-James was in Gryffindor

[Kathryn Cawte]

No: HPFGUIDX 84632


>
> Iggy here:
>
> Could this be a misquote of her...or a flint in her comments?
>
> If he was a chaser, then why did the plaque in the movie say he was a
> seeker?
>

K -

Because some idiot writer thought it'd be all cool and touching if Harry got
to see that he was following in his father's footsteps.

Iggy
> And why was he shown in OotP playing with the snitch the way he was?
>

K

Doesn't stop him being a chaser, they need quick reactions too and it's not
like he could carry a quaffle around with him. Besides it's more impressive
to play with a snitch and he was a show-off

Iggy
> And, while I don't have the books at hand right now, wasn't he mentioned
in
> the books as a seeker a couple of times?
>
>
K

It never mentions his position at all.

It's not a flint on JKR's part, if she says one thing and the movie says
another then she's right and the movie's wrong.

K