Lexicon Contmaination-James was in Gryffindor
hermowninny719
hermowninny719 at yahoo.com
Wed Nov 12 00:43:29 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 84709
> >Joe: I find in really hard to believe that Harry would never have
> asked anyone what house his parents were in in the last 5 years. I
> would think that common sense would tell us that if Harry refers to
> his father as a Gryffindor then it is most likely true.
>
> Also, Isn't James' middle name Godrick or is that just something
that
> I picked up in fan fictions. I'm not sure if it has ever been
> mentioned in canon or interviews?
>
Herm:
I agree, it *is* difficult to believe that Harry hasn't asked
questions about his parents. However, I find it even harder to
believe that Harry would have had a conversation with someone about
his parents that we weren't told about.
It just isn't clear to me that James being in Gryffindor is a fact.
He very well could have been. But if that's true, why doesn't JKR
just come out and say it? I'll tell you why, either (a) he wasn't in
Gryffindor and she doesn't want to ruin the surprise yet, or (b) she
is misleading us on purpose.
I've never heard mention of James' middle name or even initial.
Since I don't read fan fiction, you may have heard it there. If you
can find canon to support his middle name or initial, I'd be
interested to check it out.
-Hermowninny
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive