[HPforGrownups] Re: Lexicon Contmaination-James was in Gryffindor

[nymphadoraotonks at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 84713

Hermiowninny writes:

è It just isn't clear to me that James being in Gryffindor is
è a fact.   He very well could have been.  But if that's
è true, why doesn't JKR  just come out and say it?  I'll
è tell you why, either (a) he wasn't in  Gryffindor and she
è doesn't want to ruin the surprise yet, or (b) she  is
è misleading us on purpose.



( first off, so hard for me not to type Ninny as my dog is Hermione and that 
is what I am constantly calling her)
Anyway, back to topic. I wouldn't be surprised if JKR were hiding something 
from us, but I still think James was a Gryffindor. There have been so many 
clues alluding to the fact, which again makes your suspicions more than valid; 
however and this is movie contamination, but I have a point, I thought that the 
plaque in the film stated it-- I may be wrong. The only reason I bring this up 
is because on the CoS dvd, she says she has a lot of input in the interview- 
she works with her screen writers, so I would think that she would not allow a 
blatant disregard for her vision to take place. 

Again, I may be wrong. Even from all the evidence in canon, I still think the 
whole gang to be Gryffindor. It would certainly be an interesting twist to 
find initial beliefs that some of us stand by absolutely wrong.

;) Tonks


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]