How many Prefects are there?
finduilasmydarkdreamer
FinduilasMyDarkdream at lycos.de
Wed Nov 12 18:23:17 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 84818
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Robert Jones"
<jones.r.h.j at w...> wrote:
> Nothing in the plot turns on this question, but I would still like
> to know the answer: how many Prefects are there? I mean, is being
> appointed a Prefect a one-year gig, or do those who are appointed
> Prefects in their fifth year remain Prefects in their sixth and
> seventh years? In other words, at any given time, are there *two*
> Gryffindor Prefects or *six*? Maybe someone who knows the British
> boarding school system can shed some light on this.
I think the answer is most likely to be that there are two prefects
from each house at Hogwarts per year. I think so because I remember
Percy, one of the Gryffindor Prefects, leading the first years,
including Harry, up to Gryffindor Tower after the start of term feast
in PS/SS. Then, in CoS, the Polyjuiced Harry and Ron (as Crabbe and
Goyle) and later Draco, too, run into Percy who is patroulling (so it
seemed to me) the floors leading to the dungeons.
Even though Percy is probably a person who likes to give orders and
keep others from breaking rules I can't see any other reason than his
prefect's duties to make him wander the castle when everyone is told
to go straight to- and from classes preferably in company of co-
students. He doesn't seem to me like somebody who would try to catch
the Monster single-handed, so I guess his task was to prevent
students from wandering the floors of the castle without a good
reason.
Therefore I assume that when one is chosen as a prefect, he will stay
a prefect unless he acts so irresponsibly and with severe
consequences (for example endangering others) that he is inacceptable
and clearly the wrong person for this job. But as I daresay
Dumbledore has got his reasons for appointing prefects - even in
Draco's case I hope there's some urge to socialize the boy or to come
to know how he will handle a certain amount of power given to him
behind it - I don't think this will be the case very often so that
usually prefects will be in this position from their fifth- to their
seventh year.
Additionally, I think when Sirius told Harry in OotP that "Remus got
the badge" (to 'tame' his bullying Marauder friends), it is likely
Dumbledore thought he could rather manage that during three terms
instead of only one.
SnapesRaven alias FinduilasMyDarkDreamer
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/SnapesCauldron
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive