Scabbers/Percy AGAIN, AGAIN!!

nineve_laguna nineve_laguna at hotmail.com
Fri Nov 14 20:28:56 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 85011

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "justcarol67" 
<justcarol67 at y...> wrote:
> Arcum:
> > Or possibly, since he found Scabbers. Wormtail could have placed 
Percy
> > under Imperio at any time from when he was 5 to PoA, as well as in
> > GoF...
> > 
> > --Arcum
> 
> edited...
> I don't think that Scabbers/Pettigrew could do magic in his rat 
form,
> with or without a wand. (Note that PP uses Voldemort's wand to kill
> Cedric; he appears to have lost his own.) Scabbers does little 
except
> sleep until Crookshanks senses his disguise.
> Carol
+++++++++
Sorry, but I don't think we should justify Percy's behavior at all. 
As DD says himself, every family has a "bad one", including his.
Percy is not evil, but highly misguided. I had doubts about him and 
his relationship with Scabbers before, and I actually started this 
discussion, but I got a beautiful insight reply by someone (sorry, I 
don't remember the name, but follow thread by searching the 
word "Nineve") about Percy's childhood, the time he got Scabby and 
his life, and after that I am convinced that he is not in allyance 
with the Dark side, but is only a fool, as Barty Crouch Father was. 
Percy does not see his actions as highly dangerous and incriminating, 
but only as the right path to follow. He has always been a fool, and 
unfortunatelly, I have met many real people just like him.
He is deceptive as well in order to get what he wants, remember the 
bet he did with Penelope in GoF of 10 galeons, and then he admits to 
Harry he didn't have the money to pay if Harry lost? Well, that just 
shows what a selfish and greed twit he is. He annoys me endlessly, 
and this is from the very beggining.
Nineve.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive