Mark Evans

[Berit Jakobsen]

No: HPFGUIDX 85025

Tonks wrote:

> Roo, but Dumbledore would have known. At the end of OoP when DD 
sits down 
> with Harry and 'tells him everything', I would think that he would 
have mentioned 
> if Mark was relative. His disclosed everything else to Harry, so 
why keep a 
> secret that would give Harry family?  It just doesn't make sense.
I truly think DD would have said 
> something.

Me:

Give me one example, one incident where Dumbledore ever told Harry 
the whole story... :-) He never does, does he... I'm not at all sure 
he told the whole story in OoP either, though he said he did... After 
all, there are still two more books to go!  Dumbledore seems to have 
a plenty of reasons for keeping a lot of things secret for Harry, and 
I have no problem believing he would keep Mark a secret too; there's 
always a reason :-) I don't find it odd at all if Dumbledore knew 
about Mark but just didn't find it appropriate to tell Harry (yet)! 
It would be very much in line with Rowling's DD :-)

Berit