The Whole Evans Theory

Steve bboy_mn at yahoo.com
Sat Nov 15 08:57:19 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 85074

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, nymphadoraotonks at a... wrote:
> Hello bboy_mn at y...,
> 
> In reference to your comment:
> 
> è But, from a practical point of view, what are the actual
> è chances that there is not another living person on the
> è face of the earth who has not even so much as a single
> è drop of Potter or Evans blood in them?

> Tonks:
> 
> I do not deny the possibility of a distant relative. But still, if
> Petunia is Harry's 'ONLY' relative... doesn't this make for 
> something interesting? 
> -Tonks

bboy_mn:

Ok, we can approach it from that direction too. 

If the Potter and Evans family tree has been wiped from the face of
the earth then we do with out a doubt have an interesting situation;
interesting and very curious. If the ancestry is truly that bleak,
then I would hope that at some point JKR would explain how it could be so.

Of course, 'wiped from the face of the earth' is a little
melodramatic. It is possible that if the Evans and Potters typically
had very small families, had predominantly female off-springs, and
that certain old bachelors in the family failed to procreate; we
indeed have a set of circumstances where both the Evans and Potter
family trees could be very small. There could be a variety of
circumstance through which many of the branches of the family tree
'dead ended' without off-springs, like death from war, plague, etc...
and it is with in the realm of very slim possibility that the Dursley
truly are all that is left. 

But I still say that for all those circumstances to come together
would be next to impossible.

We need that next book!

bboy_mn








More information about the HPforGrownups archive