Harry's green eyes (was Ask the Question)
Caius Marcius
coriolan_cmc at hotmail.com
Sat Nov 15 19:56:35 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 85110
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com,
> > Iggy said:
> > Well, old lore tells of dragons of great age that were able to
change their
> > shape, much like an animagus. Perhaps Harry's ancestry includes a
Welsh
> > Green that married / mated into the family many years ago, so
Lily's
> > bloodline to him carries a modicum of dragon blood.
> >
> > Lauralexis said:
> > This would also explain why the AK didn't kill him. Like we saw
in GoF,
> dragons are hard to jinx/curse/hex/etc. If Harry did have dragon
blood in him,
> Voldie's curse wouldn't have worked.
The dragons in Rowling, as opposed to the dragons in (say) Wagner,
Tolkien or McCaffrey, are not depicted as being overly bright.
Magical, dangerous, deadly, yes, but possessed of a rather dinosaur-
like sensibility. Newt Scamander's classic text indicates that
dragons are accurately classified as "beasts" rather than "beings."
If a dragon were to present itself as an Animagi ancestor (as opposed
to an Animagi ancestor who could assume the form of a dragon), that
would strike me as a rather abrupt departure from Canon.
- CMC (tickling a sleeping controversy)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive