Ignorance and the toad

[Right Honorable]

No: HPFGUIDX 85120

>where in any of the books does it mention a Hogwarts choir? with 
>toads? the leaky cauldron's shot by shot comparison to the book 
>announces there is indeed such a choir and that it has been long 
>awaited...




I believe the description of "long awaited" is facetious, since there 
have not been any Hogwarts choruses, much less ones carrying giant 
toads, in canon. I think it's scandalous that there hasn't been any 
organized student music at Hogwarts beyond one singing of the school 
song in PS/SS and "Weasley is Our King." This is the first film 
departure from canon that I wholeheartedly applaud.




Er, I should probably shut up now since this is veering dangerously 
off topic.




I'm away laughing on a fast camel,




Mun42