No: HPFGUIDX 85208 Blueangel wrote: I found the prophecy a bit of a let down. Especially without knowing how or why the Potter defied Voldemort or why he chose Harry not Neville. Me: But we do know why he chose Harry rather than Neville. Dumbledore's words in OoP: "He saw himself in you before he had even seen you." Berit