The Gang of Slytherins
ghinghapuss
rredordead at aol.com
Wed Nov 19 15:27:43 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 85437
Carol wrote:
> <Snip> Maybe the members of the Slytherin gang who didn't Death
> Eaters were girls, notably Narcissa? Not to sound sexist, but it
> doesn't seem that any women other than Bellatrix became Death
Eaters.
Now me:
I think we have to be careful making the assumption that Bellatrix is
the only female Death Eater although it certainly looks that way.
Most of the DE's named by Voldemort in the graveyard are male. (I've
always questioned if the DE's who showed up or were mentioned by
Voldemort are the only ones?) Maybe the DE's are mostly men and
perhaps Voldemort's inner circle is male dominated. But I wouldn't be
surprised if that changes in the last 2 books.
It seemed to me that the early HP books were very 'boy's adventure'
dominated with Harry and Ron being active and having the fun, and
occasionally helped by their reactive, faithful, bookish, sidekick,
the token female: Hermione. And I have to add there is nothing wrong
with that. But all that dramatically changed with the injection of
Girl Power in Book 5. Perhaps, as JKR's daughter is getting older,
she got a crisis of conscience and had to add a few stronger female
role models. Whatever the reason, we suddenly had the introduction
of the retooled Hermione, Ginny and Molly, along with new characters
of Luna, Umbridge and Bellatrix. (Ok she previously appeared in Book4
but we didn't know who she was until book5).
I wouldn't be surprised if a few female Death Eaters showed up soon.
Perhaps they will be newly initiated from some characters we've
already met.
Mandy
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive