[HPforGrownups] Narcissa Malfoy (the real Spy)

Laura Ingalls Huntley lhuntley at fandm.edu
Thu Nov 20 05:56:48 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 85521

zihav:
>> JKR also said that Snape will fall in love at some point.

Janet Anderson:
> Where? When?  Inquiring minds want to know.

I am also interested in seeing this quote from myself.

zihav:
>> What if he
>> all ready is and it's Narcissa.

Janet Anderson:
> Narcissa's a married woman.  I will be very surprised if JKR has such a
> relationship in her book (although Diana Wynne Jones did so in "The 
> Crown of
> Dalemark," but not with a character as high-profile as Snape).

Well, it could be *unrequited* love, although I'm a tentative supporter 
of LOLLIPOPS, myself.

However, I disagree strongly that JKR wouldn't put "such a 
relationship" in the books.  Oh, I don't think she'd hit us over the 
head with something like  "Narcissa Malfoy is cheating on Lucius with 
Severus Snape! That means they're having SEX!"

But I *do* think she might have something subtler, such as "Narcissa 
Malfoy was forced by societal/familial/economic pressure to marry 
Lucius, but the love that she and Snape share is still strong."

I'm not saying that I think JKR would endorse extramarital affairs, 
just that she's the type of author that would go ahead and put them in 
her book if she wanted to.

Janet Anderson:
> What about Tonks?  She'd make him wash his hair and change his 
> underwear ...
> in fact, I foresee that if Snape actually does get a girlfriend, we'll 
> be
> able to tell by the improvement in his hygiene.
>

It's that always the way?

Laura





More information about the HPforGrownups archive