Challenging Lexicon timeline (was Ron's dead brother)

[Geoff Bannister]

No: HPFGUIDX 85532

> > I found it and yes, he does say seven years.  Okay, I get that, 
but 
> > why is it automatically assumed that Charlie won the cup the last 
> > year he was at school?  After all, Wood describes Harry as better 
> > than Charlie, and it still takes three years for their team to 
win 
> > the cup.  Also, if Charlie left before Wood even got there, how 
> would 
> > Wood be able to compare their flying styles?  
> > 
 
Geoff:
We had a long thread on this or a very similar matter a couple of 
months ago, which might help with the present discuaaion. 
It's "Charlie Weasley's Age" and starts at message 76208.

Geoff