Narcissa Malfoy (the real Spy)

[zihav]

No: HPFGUIDX 85561

Tom said:
> As the subject line says I think Narcissa is the ture spy for the 
> Order and Snape is only the go between. Snape can't possibly go 
> back to the Death Eaters he would be killed right away.
> <Heavy Snip> 
> JKR also said that Snape will fall in love at some point. What if 
> he all ready is and it's Narcissa. This could explain why he treats 
> Draco so well when he knows his father is a DE. 
 
ghinghapuss:
> First off, as weak as it is, I love the idea, simply because I 
> personally have been intrigued by Narcissa's character for a while 
> and desperately want her to become a player in the saga.  But we 
know 
> so little about her it all becomes purely speculative.  And an 
> affaire with Snape, or even James and having Draco being Harry's 
half 
> brother, is very tantalizing.  I have also hoped that she is one of 
> Lily's school friends (along with Alice Longbottom) who can't come 
> forward to help Harry because of who her family is.  But it's all 
> delightful speculation which I can't possibly back up. :-)


Tom:
Hello again, wow this has been taken way out of context. I only said 
that Snape might be in love with Narcissa, but have no canon to back 
that up. It's complete speculation based on one of JKR's online 
chat's (which I can't find at the moment needless to say) when she's 
asked if Snape would fall in love. That *doesn't* mean he's having an 
affair, just that he has strong feels about her. She might not feel 
the same way or even know.

I think the point I was trying to make that Narcissa is in a much 
better position to be the spy for the Order and not Snape. We do know 
Snape is getting information, but from who and how? Narcissa is the 
who I believe and I just wanted to establish motive.

I do like the idea that Lily and Narcissa and Alice Longbottom all 
went to school together and knew each other and maybe very good 
friends, just like Harry's father and his friends.

Hopefully I've clarified my theory...

Tom