Narcissa Malfoy (the real Spy)

[justcarol67]

No: HPFGUIDX 85618

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "zihav" <lynch at a...> wrote:
> Greeting:
> 
> First off, sorry if this has been mentioned before, I did a search 
> and could find anything on it as far as Narcissa is concerned. I have 
> been thinking about this since GoF.
> 
> As the subject line says I think Narcissa is the ture spy for the 
> Order and Snape is only the go between. Snape can't possibly go back 
> to the Death Eaters he would be killed right away.
> 
> Now why: 
> 
> In GoF when we first meet her she has a look of something bad 
> smelling right under her nose. What if she hates her husband, but 
> can't leave without leaving her son behind which she wouldn't do. 
> 
> She hates what her husband becasue what he has done to her son 
> (making him a second generation DE) and wants to protect him from 
> that life of going no where.
> 
> She's the one who prevented Draco from going to Drumstrang. She's 
> always sending sweets and seems to be the one more concerned about 
> her son's welfare than the father.
> 
> I think she has a lot of motives to be the spy and also she's in a 
> better postion to know what's going on with all the Death Eaters and 
> Voldermort than Snape at this time.
> 
> JKR also said that Snape will fall in love at some point. What if he 
> all ready is and it's Narcissa. This could explain why he treats 
> Draco so well when he knows his father is a DE. If caught they could 
> claim that Snape put a curse on her and take the fall and being good 
> at Occulmency would be enough to get away with it.
> 
> The only hole is in OotP where Kreacher goes out to the other Black 
> family, but that might have been discounted as not being very 
> important becasue he couldn't say anything about the Order.
> 
> What do you think?
>   
>    Tom

I haven't read the other responses so maybe this has been mentioned,
but aren't you forgetting the treacherous House Elf Kreacher, who
straight ran to Narcissa when Sirius told him to get out of the house?
Narcissa may not be a Death Eater like her sister (at least not that
we know of), but she's deinitely on the Dark side. (And sending sweets
to Draco is indulging him as Petunia indulges Dudley.)

I can't imagine Snape and Narcissa in love. Besides, it would be an
adulterous love, and JKR isn't going to write on a topic like that
even in Book 6 or 7. Also I agree that Snape can't go to Voldemort
without being killed, but I think he *can* go to Lucius Malfoy with
some cunning lie about why he wasn't with the Death Eaters in the
graveyard. He hasn't studied occlumency (and legilmency) for nothing.
I have an idea that Malfoy suspects him but also greatly
underestimates him. At least I sincerely hope so.
 
Carol