Neville and the Clean Break

dmoorehpnc dmoorehpnc at yahoo.com
Fri Nov 21 19:18:31 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 85645

Entropy wrote:
> >From:  
> >thought: perhaps her motives for keeping Neville in a
> >bumbling state are not so evil after all. If Voldemort knows that
> >Neville is near to useless as a wizard can come, and his parents
> >remain in a curse-induced stupor, then he certainly would have 
little or no interest in harming the family any further. (Snip)
>  
Iggy wrote: 
> Bouncing off of this particular thought, it could be that Gran has 
heard
> the prophecy somehow, and understands that Neville could still,
> potentially, be the one mentioned.  (snip)
>I think Hagrid would have been just as likely to be sent out
> after Neville as he was to get Harry...)

ME dmoorehpnc
I'm with you Iggy, Dumbledore's explaination to Harry at the end of 
OoP about the prophecy doesn't hold up for me. I think Dumbledore is 
holding something back from Harry (so what else is new?). How will 
Harry kill Voldomort unless he gets the jump on him? As we've seen in 
GoF both wands cancel each other out. I not only believe that Neville 
will have a big role in the books to come but he may indeed be 
the "MAN" to get Voldemort.

dmoorehpnc






More information about the HPforGrownups archive