Bang! You're Dead. (was:Voldemorts animus...)

[mightymaus75]

No: HPFGUIDX 85952

>>> Kneasy wrote:
>>> Why not  unforgivable curses? After all they are only
>>> unforgivable when used against *people* and Voldy is no longer
>>> human. 
>> 
>> Then Siriusly Snapey Susan wrote:
>> This comes up ALL THE TIME.  Can you, Kneasy, or someone else
>> PLEASE enlighten me as to why this is true?  I myself have stated
>> that I believe he has chosen a life which is less than truly
>> LIVING...but I cannot get a handle on where people get it that
>> either 1) Voldy is not a human being; or 2) Voldy is immortal.
>>  What have I missed?
>
> To which Kneasy replied:   
> Pleased to. You must have skipped over it somehow.
> GoF, graveyard scene, Voldy addressing the returned DEs.
> 
><snipped GoF, graveyard scene quotes>
> 


There is also Hagrid's comment is PS/SS: "Some say he died. 
Codswallop, in my opinion. Dunno if he had enough human left in him 
to die."

I do however wonder about the morality of Kneasy's statement that 
it's okay to use the unforgivable curses on Voldemort just as long as 
he is no longer human. It's precisely this sort of attitude that 
results in resentment among the non-humans.
 
-Maus