[HPforGrownups] Re: Traitor yet again

[KT Waters]

No: HPFGUIDX 86128

Carol:

>Harry doesn't trust Snape, but
>Dumbledore does. And that trust has to be fully merited IMO.


Okay Harry hates Snape. Why? Because Snape picks on him. Okay, that's cool, fair enough. Sirius says the world isn't split into nice people and Death Eaters. Snape isn't nice, but he's not evil, is he? 

He risked his life for the Order loads, from what I gather - all that spying. I think his trust is fully merited. IMHO, I think he has been doing better then any of the Maruauders. Pettigrew went evil, Black couldn't control his emotions and landed himself in jail, Potter died and Lupin... well we don't know anything about Lupin at all really, do we? Who is he really? Is he married? What does he do that he leaves the house for "long periods of time"? 

Until we have proof on that, I would say that Snape is a much better person than they. Okay so he's not as nice as they, maybe, but Black wasn't nice either, not to people he didn't like. Snape's the same. I think they must be related, it is so uncanny...

Jadeau xxx


---------------------------------
Download Yahoo! Messenger now for a chance to WIN Robbie Williams "Live At Knebworth DVD"

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]