Who inherits 12 Gimmauld Place?
o_caipora
o_caipora at yahoo.com
Thu Oct 2 14:30:21 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 82086
Message 75604 will drop you into the midst of a recent thread on
this, with a list of links to older threads on the same topic.
"Robert Jones" <jones.r.h.j at w...> wrote:
> Maybe the property of condemned
> prisioners goes to the Ministry. (In colonial New England, the
laws
> of England of the time applied, and the property of executed
> prisoners was forfeited to the colony.)
Interesting. IIRC this happens in David Copperfield; his benefactor
returns to England in defiance of the terms of his exile, and
forfeits his fortune.
> If the MoM doesn't get the property and Sirius didn't leave a will,
> what laws of inheritance apply? Not the Laws of England but the
> Laws of Rowling -- JKR may have some clever and funny law of
> intestate succession in mind for the Wizarding World.
Literature may be a better guide than law; Rowling is certainly more
familiar with Austen and Dickens than with Black. Entailment is old
in law and literature, turning up in the Canterbury Tales.
England has a tradition of primogeniture and male inheritance.
Scotland AFAIK has for centuries given greater respect to women's
right to inheirit.
Two clues that entailment is in the wings are that a) Sirius
inherited the house despite his mother's intense dislike of him,
which argues she didn't have the power to disinherit; and b) Rowling
so carefully showed us that Draco is the closest male heir.
She could have had the family tree show Draco as a relative without
making him the closest male heir. She didn't. I smell plot twist.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive