It isn't murder ...

[berkana_dianic]

No: HPFGUIDX 82187

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Richard" <darkmatter30 at y...> 
wrote:
> Richard here ...
> 
> I'm getting a bit tired of all the talk of murder, round here, at 
> least to the extent that so many seem to have decided that Harry 
must 
> be a murderer if he kills Voldemort.  
........................................
I agree with you Richard. Voldemort has tried to kill Harry since he 
was a baby. He even invaded Quirell (wrong spelling I think), just to 
get to Harry. He tortured Harry over his own fathers grave and 
killed Cedric whilst he stood beside Harry. If Harry was to kill 
Voldemort, in the end and I truly hope he does, then NO it wouldn't 
be classed as murder, because Voldemort has tried to kill him more 
than once. That to me is self defense, but now wasn't the prophecy 
in OotP something like One can not survive without the other, so if 
Harry dies, then Voldemort dies?.....It has been a long time since I 
read the book, so I am so sorry if I have just come up with that 
prophecy, but if I am correct, then there is no point talking about 
what if Harry murders Voldemort, or visa versa, because when Harry 
dies, then so will Voldemort and visa versa


ml


joanna

I am going to read OotP again starting from tonight, but at the 
moment I am on GoF for the 14th time...I love the book