Could Time-Turner be used to save Black?

nianya_c nianya_c at yahoo.com
Fri Oct 3 18:39:36 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 82221

> Alshain:
 Sorry, but no go. The point of time-turners is that you can only 
prevent events which haven't happened yet, not change the past. 
Sirius hadn't yet been Kissed when Harry and Hermione woke up, so I 
think your memory deceives you a little bit. If Fudge had had the 
Kiss administered as soon as he got his hands on Sirius, no time-
turner in the world could have saved him, which is why Dumbledore is 
in such a hurry.
> 

Have to disagree on the time turner issue. If it can only apply to 
events that haven't happened yet, how can Hermione turn back time to 
attend a class/exam that is already over? Throughout PoA she was 
doing just that going back to attend classes which were already 
finished.

Nianya

P.S. I think Sirius will come back in some form or fashion (whether 
alive or not) but the time-turner will not play a part in this.







More information about the HPforGrownups archive