What was Luna going to say?
urghiggi
urghiggi at yahoo.com
Thu Oct 9 22:32:59 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 82618
Sylvia wrote:
> I did remember that DD talked about the locked door, but amid all
> that waffle, he never actually says what it contains. (I sometimes
> think it would help Harry considerably if Dumbledore was a little
> more straight-forward with him. Why not just tell him what was in
> there?) The general consensus seems to be that it contained Love butI
> should still have liked to know what Luna thought. I also wondered
> about Ravenclaw Bookworm's point that Luna and Dumbledore might not
> have been talking about the same locked door.
Urghiggi said:
I don't know for sure what's in there. But I think I can guess what HERMIONE
thought Luna was going to say.
Remember ... Luna thinks Fudge is tres evil -- a notorious goblin killer -- and
is also keeping an army of heliopaths somewhere at the MoM. Heliopaths --
fire spirits -- certainly could melt the knife Harry was trying to use to jimmy the
door. I expect Hermione was waiting for Luna to come out again with the
"heliopath hypothesis," which Hermione would naturally refer to as
"something blibbering..."
Pls note that I personally don't think it was heliopaths behind that door...
though I would not at all be surprised if they do indeed turn out to be real,
somehow or other.
Urghiggi, Chgo
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive