Who Killed Sirius Black? (Was:Re: OoP - GUILTY Dumbledore)

[KathyK]

No: HPFGUIDX 82764

Annemehr:

> Annemehr commences kicking and screaming against one of the more
> shocking aspects of Guilty!Dumbledore: that DD himself is 
responsible
> for the death of Sirius Black.
> 
<massive snipping>
> 
> If Sirius was going to die, it was because JKR arranged it, not
> Dumbledore.
> 
 
KathyK turns to her new friend sitting beside her and says:

Look at those folks arguing about whether or not Dumbledore killed 
Sirius.  You and I both know you're the one responsible.  You threw 
that second jet of light, not Bellatrix, and certainly not 
Dumbledore.  But I don't know if anyone will believe it or accept 
it.  What do you think, Killer!Lupin?

KathyK (who does have arguments for this and promises to post them 
very soon but right now she's late for work.  She also apologizes to 
everyone for the brief post but she couldn't resist, you see.)