James and Snape vs. Harry and Peter

lziner lziner at yahoo.com
Mon Oct 13 01:30:07 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 82803

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "cookiemacster" 
<cookiemacster at y...> wrote:
>  Just a thought: Having read numerous posts and not seeing anything 
> about this, I decided I'd pick your brains on the subject!
>       Okay, I was curious if you all think there is a "magical 
bond" 
> between James and Snape, like there (supposedly) is between Harry 
> and Peter. 
>        At the end of book 3 Dumbledore tells Harry that by 
> allowing Peter to live, saving his life, Peter is now in debt to 
> him. Would Snape, by being saved by James, be in some way in debt 
to 
> James? If so, did Snape ever repay James? Maybe James died before 
> Snape could repay his debt and in a future book he will do so by 
> svaing/helping Harry...?   
>       

When Quirrel (Voldemort) was trying to hurt Harry during the 
quidditch match in SS, Snape was countering the spell.  I don't have 
the book handy.  However, I remember Hermoine setting Snapes robe on 
fire - thinking he was hexing Harry.  On that occasion, Snape may 
have been saving Harry as repayment to James.  

lziner 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive