Pippin, you've done it again! (Was -who will betray the Order?)

[hickengruendler]

No: HPFGUIDX 82815

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "slgazit" <slgazit at s...> wrote:
 
 
> 
> And as for the quote above, there is a lot more evidence in OoP 
that 
> Snape was weakening Harry's defenses against Voldemort during the 
> occlumency lessons,  

This was Ron and later Harry's assumption. However, Snape's actions 
seem to contradict this. His first reaction, when he saw that Harry 
dreamed from the corridor, was, that he was worried. Harry recognized 
it, and he was happy because Snape treated him unfairly only moments 
before. But why should Snape be worried about the dream, if he 
secretly works for Voldemort? He hasn't even a reason to act, as if 
he is worried, because Harry didn't know at this point, how important 
his dreams are. Snape also told Dumbledore at once about Harry's 
dreams. Why should he do this, if he were on Voldemort's side?

I also want to mention, that Harry didn't do, what Snape told him to 
do. Harry didn't practise, therefore, it is no wonder, that he wasn't 
able to learn Occlumency.

That said, I want do add, that I don't think Lupin is the traitor 
either, or Molly Weasley, for that matter. After all, Harry's dead 
body was a part of her boggart. Maybe JK is nice, and the traitor (if 
there is any!) will be someone, we don't know to much about, yet.

Hickengruendler