Gryffindor Staircase
adsong16
gorda_ad at hotmail.com
Thu Oct 16 17:01:33 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 83017
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "fourjays22" <jayandjay22 at h...>
wrote:
> I was curious what role (if any) people think the Gryffindor
> staircase might play in books six and seven.
[snip]
> Could this be a key location of some sort of final battle if/when LV
> enters Hogwarts?
[more snips]
Excellent question. My thoughts on the staircase: I agree with Richard that it is
the role of the staircase is to chastise boys for trying to get up there rather than
actually preventing them from doing so. I also agree that the staricase
probably is bewitched beyond the steps, that you can't just grab a flying
device or disguise yourself as a girl in order to get up there. (I'm sure th
Founders thought of these, I am also sure that all girsl dormitories are so
bewitched, not just Gryffindor)
When I first read this passage I figured that JKR was pointing out something
about the workings of relationships at Hogwarts. Thus far we know that
people, when they want to be alone, seek out dark places on the grounds,
such as the bushes at the Yule Ball. We also know that Harry kissed Cho in
the Room of Requirement. Harry hasn't had the chance or need to go making
out somewhere on the grounds (yet) so we don't really know other places
couples go on a regular basis. The fact that JKR tells us that the girls
staircases are bewitched so that boys can't get in there seems significant in
that it means a couple needs to go elsewhere to meet in private... hope for the
various shippers out there that JKR will bring this up again. ;-)
As for a site for later batlles with the Death Eaters, I just don't see this
happening. Of all places at HOgwarts, I just don't see our little heros hiding in
a girls dormitory, nor do I think LV and Co. would be deterred by it... I could be
wrong, of course.
I also think this may come into play as a kind of a clue to later mysteries, for
example if someone breaks into the girls dormitory in later books, for some
reason, and we are led to conclude that it must be a woman, because of the
staircase... or some other such ocurrance.
I do wonder, however... Prof. McGonagall has gone up to the boys' tower
when there's been trouble, for example when Harry got sick after his vision of
the snake attacking Mr. Weasley. How do male Heads of House go to help if
there's a problem in the girls dormitories? [this is not really important, I guess,
I'm just curious =)]
Gorda
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive