Are we missing the point of the #6 Rumor?

meriaugust meriaugust at yahoo.com
Thu Oct 16 17:30:00 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 83026

> Cassie wrote:
> 
> > But what minimal (or even some major) injury couldn't be fixed by a night or 
> > so in the hospital wing? 

I think we are missing the point of this possible quote about book 6. 
The question shoudn't be what body part gets injured and why can't it 
be fixed by magic (since we all know there are limitations to what 
magic can and can't do), IMHO the question should be HOW does poor 
Harry get this injury? Surely not falling down the stairs at Privet 
Drive or taking a nosedive off his Firebolt. I think the hint here is 
that there will be some sort of battle (duh) and that maybe this time 
Harry will again escape with his life, but may not be so lucky in the 
future. Or could this possibly be like Luke Skywalker's robotic hand 
in Star Wars, a weakness that he just has to deal with. This could 
very well be foreshadowing a Darth Vader is Luke's father type 
revelation from LV. Oooh, I just shuddered from the possibilites. 
Dumbledore as Harry's long lost granddad? LV as Harry's even longer 
lost granddad? Lily as a Slytherin descendant? James as the second to 
last Gryffindor? Mark Evans a cousin Harry never knew? Who knows. Any 
thoughts? 

Meri (who really hopes that Harry won't have to leap off Cloud City 
to escape from Voldemort this time around) 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive