Tonks - The Death Eater (reprise)

[Mausita]

No: HPFGUIDX 83057

"Inge" <Elvishooked at h...> wrote:
> I posted a theory on Tonks a short while back but had no respons at 
> all. I wonder why. Maybe the idea has already been discussed and I 
> didn't notice - and in that case, Im sorry for reposting. If that is 
> the case please point me in the direction where to find it.
> 
> Here goes again, and I do hope for some sort of reply this time :)
> 
> 
> In OotP we are introduced to Tonks, the Metamorphmagus. It seemed 
> wrong that she didn't become known later in the books as someone who 
> actually *used* her skills as a Metamorphmagus.
> So this idea came to me. What if indeed she does use her skills and 
> changes into someone else on a regular basis. Into someone we already 
> know but who is no longer of any real importance in the books - at 
> least not to us, the readers.
> What if Snape is not the spy after all - it would be a bit too 
> obvious if he were, wouldn't it? So - who else would be able to take 
> the position of Dumbledore's spy and be able to get very close to 
> Voldemort without him even suspecting there's a spy in his midst?
> Tonks might be the one.
> But for her to do so she would need to take the place of someone who 
> is no longer around - someone *Voldemort* THINKS is still around - 
> but isn't.
> 
> Whatever happened to Barty Ferm Jr after he had his soul sucked out? 
> Do we know? 
> Does Voldemort have any way of knowing what really happened to Barty 
> Ferm Jr at the end of GOF? Who could have told him?
> 
> What if Barty Ferm Jr still exists - on special occassions. What if 
> Tonks could Metamorph into Ferm Jr and take his place at the DE 
> meetings and get information directly from Voldemort to pass on to 
> the Order.
> Now - how would Tonks know when the DE's are summoned by Voldemort? 
> Snape would tell her - because he would know!
> 
> I love the idea that Tonks Metamorphmagus'es herself into Barty Ferm 
> Jr and attends the DE meetings.
> 
> I can't think of anyone - but one - who could have told Voldemort 
> that his loyal supporter Ferm Jr was sucked dry at the end of GOF - 
> and that would be Lucius. But would Fudge really have any reason to 
> have told Lucius about that incident?
> 
> What do you think? 
> 
> Inge
*********
Since you sooooooo want a reply, I figured I would give you one.
 
Not a bad idea.  However, it's not said that Tonks can morph into other/certain people but change her appearance.  Plus, she would have to know Barty quite well to pull it off, and he was under an invisibility cloak for 12-13 years.  Crouch was able to do Moody because Moody's demeanor and behavior are so well known.  I would assume that what holds true for animagi holds for metamorphmagi; that sex cannot be changed.  Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't Tonks always appear as women?  Her height did not vary either, right?  Plus, Harry/Ron = Crabbe/Goyle when using Polyjuice Potion.  Hermione was supposed to be Milicent.  Same sex, different morphs.
 
Marci (who typed this up and it did not post, had to retype; added some stuff, hope the same message came across. lol)



---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
The New Yahoo! Shopping - with improved product search

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]