How does Snape get away with it?
evil_sushi2003
evil_sushi2003 at hotmail.com
Tue Oct 21 17:29:59 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 83264
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "augustinapeach"
<augustinapeach at y...> wrote:
> Ever since finding out that Snape is spying on Voldemort for
> Dumbledore, I've wondered how he can get away with it. In PS/SS,
> Voldemort was on the back of Quirrell's head while Snape was
warning
> Q to figure out "where his loyalties lie" (quote may be wrong,
don't
> have books with me here). Even through that purple turban, he was
> bound to have heard the conversation. Then in GoF, it's likely
> Crouch Jr., posing as Moody, overheard sensitive information that
he
> passed on to Voldemort via the eagle owl. So it seems to me that
> Voldemort would know where *Snape's* loyalties lie. All that
makes
> convince them he is still a loyal DE and that makes him useful
> enough to keep alive? Is he being set up for a scene in which V
> reveals that he knows Snape is a double agent before killing Snape?
Yeah I've been wondering that a lot lately too, but in OotP, Sirius
tells Harry that Snape is a very skilled Occlumens, and apparently
these Occlumens can hide their thoughts from others, and thats what I
presumed Snape was doing.
But your point brings up a question, why is Voldy keeping Snape on,
when we are led to believe in GoF that he is aware of losing Snape?
I think that Snape is definitely the one who V is referring to here,
as I don't think JK would have put that in for the sake of it.
I wuold say that even though Snape is a skilled Occlumens, Voldy
used something... maybe Snape's anger and frustration at MWPP, we
all know that he pretty much loses it every time they are brought
up... and saw through Snape's defences to confirm what he already
suspected.
I would think that V is now waiting for Snape to become a more
valuable character: I doubt that anyone save Dumbledore would miss
him at the moment. And then Snape will heroicly die. And everyone
would miss him.
Personally he's my favourite character, but I still think he'll be
killed off.
Sorry, I've probably been doing a whole lot of rambling...
*~evil_sushi
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive