Barty Crouch Jr. not soul-sucked?

chiara.fantoni at cec.eu.int chiara.fantoni at cec.eu.int
Wed Oct 22 07:48:37 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 83309

Kate wrote:

>Unfortunately, Voldemort knew that his minion would be in trouble 
>and Apparated just outside Hogwarts, guised as a dementor.  He had 
>no problem getting into the school and pretending to suck the soul 
>from Crouch.  This had been his most faithful servant and would be 
>rewarded greatly.  Besides, Voldemort has other plans for the boy...
>plans that may prove to be the end of Harry Potter once and for all.
 
Sorry if I bring back this long-forgotten message.

Are you implying that Crouch Jr.'s sentence might have been faked?

That the Dementors really never sucked his soul?

It was just a joke?

Can someone, even LV, fake a Dementor, chill and darkness and all included?

He can certainly dress like one, but what about the "accessories"?

I'm a very late HP fan (only read the books after having been taken somewhat
against my consent to see the second film) and I'm also a rare one-time only
reader, but I had the impression that once the Dementors are there there is
little you can do unless you have a Patronus at hand.

And I suppose Barty didn't, or did he?

Chiara





More information about the HPforGrownups archive