Lily and James not Aurors (Was - Could Harry really be an Auror?)
Kirstini
kirst_inn at yahoo.co.uk
Wed Oct 22 21:51:13 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 83352
I wrote:
>>Neither of Harry's parents were old enough to be fully-fledged
Aurors>>
To which Salit replied:
> We don't know that, do we?>
'Fraid so. Check out the Lexicon at http://www.hp-
lexicon.org/james.html. James, Lily et al were born in 1960. By 1981,
they would have been 21 - possibly a few of them still 20 - and if
full Aurors then only just graduated. And to have escaped Voldemort
three times in that small period between graduation and Halloween?
Unless Auror training includes a massive practical element (ie, out
there, fighting on the field), or was speeded up during the war, I
imagine that they were working against Voldemort in completely
different ways, to give them the practical experience of having
escaped him three times between leaving school and Sybil making her
prediction. They had done all this escaping before the prophecy, not
as a result of it. He must have been after them for some other
reason - and why pursue Aurors-in-training so personally? Why not
just get a minion to do it? Also remember that the 20-year old Lily
was heavily pregnant during what would have been her final, and
presumably most intensive year of Auror training (asuming that they
follow Hogwarts academic years). Not quite "too young" - my emphasis
was misleading, sorry - to be Aurors, but very nearly, and too young
to have any significance within that career path.
Dumbledor may recruit Aurors, but it strikes me that training Aurors
is the Ministry's way of policing Dark activity, not his.
That "meddling" = spying seems more likely to me. Somehow.
Kirstini
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive