The VEIL

[nianya_c]

No: HPFGUIDX 83453

Phil Posted:

Third Idea about the VEIL.....

3. The voices Harry and Luna heard are Arthur, Molly, and Bill   
Weasley. Bill works at Gringotts and the Weasleys are in the    
Gringott tunnel area preparing for Sirius' arrival (following     
Dumbledore's plan as postulated by the T-BAY experts). Harry even 
calls out "Ron" at one point thinking he hears his voice from the 
veil. Any canon on whether Arthur or Bill sound like Ron?

.....
I have most faith in idea 3 above. This may mean that Sirius is 
still alive but I must stress that I am ambivalent (have I used that 
correctly) about his state of health. Harry believes that Sirius 
died and his attitude and actions at the MoM and in the future 
require him to continue to believe Sirius dead until Voldemort is 
defeated.
> 
Most, if not all, postees seem to agree that Sirius is truly dead, 
but purely from the book, the reader cannot be certain. The 
certainty that Sirius is dead comes from a JKR interview does it 
not? She cried when she 'killed' him. But could this emotion be not 
from the death of character Sirius but because of the effect the 
apparent death was to have on Harry. Remember Dumbledore has already 
put Harry through 10 years of misery with the Dursleys so another 2 
years (only we know it's 2 years, not DD etc <g>) for Harry 
believing Sirius is dead for the good of the PLAN is acceptable to 
DD but, IMHO, worse when Harry learns the truth than if Sirius has 
really died.

Nianya Relied:

I totally agree that this theory is possible and posted a similar 
suggestion on another board a few weeks ago that Sirius may have 
faked his death as part of Dumbledore's plan and that JKR was so 
upset due to Harry's reaction. This definitely could fit with the 
overall story plan so far and Lupin and the others were way too 
happy after his death....almost like they knew something was up.

Nianya

....who completed OWLS in English and Lit.....NEWTS in Law and would 
have alot more fun in life as an Auror.