How does Snape get away with it?

finduilasmydarkdreamer FinduilasMyDarkdream at lycos.de
Thu Oct 23 11:56:31 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 83468

Hi!

Yesterday I followed an interesting thread in this discussion and 
stated my opinion about it. But I obviously didn't refer to a 
specific paragraph so I was kindly asked to do so. I see the point in 
it and here is my addition at the top (and what I posted yesterday, too).
: )

 I  refer to - what I call "aforementioned thoughts" - evil 
sushi's posting from October 21st. There augustinapeach was quoted 
writing, "Even through that purple turban, he [Voldemort] was 
bound to have heard the conversation. Then in GoF, it's likely 
Crouch Jr., posing as Moody, overheard sensitive information", and 
evil sushi hinted the Occlumency might be the reason for Snape having 
managed to get away with it until now. These are some of the thoughts 
I had myself and when I read them here I thought I could add a piece 
to it. 

In the first place I wonder which turn of fate Snape is going to face 
should Voldemort really have inside informations from Kreacher. 


Responding to augustinapeach & co I write:-

'Now this is an interestig point! 
*flutters down onto her Master's shoulder, becoming one with his 
silky black hair*
 
I thought about this quite a lot and since OotP I wonder, apart 
from the aforementioned thoughts, what Kreacher the evil little House-
Elf did when Sirius told him to go. Did he report to Voldemort 
classified information about the Order? Its members and perhaps even 
parts of their plans...??!?
 
Even though a House-Elf has to be 'loyal' to his family, when there 
are two different masters he serves, isn't there the possibility 
that he has to spill out everything valuable? Even if it weren't so, 
there'd still be the possibility to punish himself afterwards (as 
mentioned in the book). Dobby did it, too, so Kreacher's evil 
nature could just as likely have made him turn from Sirius 
once and for all.(Oh how I hate that stinking elf for luring Sirius 
into such a trap!)

 
I wonder who it is Kreacher called his 'mistress'. Could it be 
Narcissa Malfoy, Sirius's relative and thus also part of the family 
Kreacher has to serve? 
And was 'she' really 'upstairs'?
 
What do you think?
 
SnapesRaven alias FinduilasMyDarkDreamer'
















More information about the HPforGrownups archive