Dobby revisited

[Granny Goodwitch]

No: HPFGUIDX 83605


26Oct03 

B Arrowsmith wrote:

JKR has famously said that she nearly gave the game away in CoS. The
'why' of it all. Could this be part of it? A critical connection that
was unsuspected, with the behaviour of Elves the linking clue through
three books? 

Granny responds:

Thanks Arrowsmith!  I'm still in total agreement with you.  In spite of recent posts quoting Dobby in CoS:"... life has improved for my kind since you triumphed over He Who Must Not Be Named....", I have suspected and still suspect a critical connection with the behaviour of Elves.  And, the best evidence is, as you cited, that as far as we know  Harry is not related to Dobby's then masters, the Malfoys.

 

 Penny Bee wrote:
"I think that somehow Harry is related to LV ... ! I'm leaning toward 
the idea that somehow the connection is through Lily's family (and 
somehow Aunt Petunia is tied in)...but there really isn't any canon 
yet to back this up. "

Granny:

Yes, Penny.  As an old mystery lover, I've been thinking along these lines too.  Do you ever get the feeling that JKR was an Agatha Christie fan in her youth?  I get the same kind of thrill of searching for clues in the HP Saga as I do in the Christie mysteries.  And so far, the clues have always had a way of being tied together.


Granny Goodwitch



---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
Exclusive Video Premiere - Britney Spears

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]