What's Sirius There For?

[Paula Gaon]

No: HPFGUIDX 83855

30Oct03  
 
*Snip*
Mandy wrote:
Sirius was there to illustrate the terrible pain of loosing a beloved 
one. Pain and loss that  is different to Harry than the loss of his 
parents who he didn't know. I'm afraid Sirius is not coming back. 
Sorry to all you Sirius fans. But that is life, and the sheer 
brilliance of JKR's writing is it realism. 
*End Snip*
 
Paula now:
 
I have to disagree.  A recent post pointed to the fact that Sirius had the important task of exposing Wormtail, Pettigrew as the murderer of  Harry's parents and traitor to LV's side.  As I posted a few days ago: Even Nearly Headless Nick's certainty that Sirius has "gone on" is not so convincing when he himself (Nick) admits that he knows nothing of the secrets of death.  Remember too that upon hearing of Surius' demise that his great-great grandfather, Phineus immediately leaves his frame in Dumbledore's office and could have possibly fled to his frame at Grimmauld Place, maybe to inform Sirius that Harry thought he was dead and was having a talk with DD.  Remember that Phineus is already dead, so wouldn't he have known if Sirius had died?  In addition, Phinius spoke to Harry from his picture frame at Grimmauld Place telling him not to leave.  He's becoming more and more involved in the saga's plot.  With JKR's talent for plot development, I still feel that Sirius is among us, but
 has had to resort to drastic measures to go undercover.  The Malfoys certainly know (and have probably told others) about Sirius' habit of sometimes going out as Snuffles.  So, "death" behind the Veil would have been the perfect opportunity to create another cover.  Lucius Malfoy was even present.  No, no, I'm not giving up on Sirius so easily.  I'm still holding on to a ray of hope that he's fighting the Dark Lord.
 
~Paula "Griff" Gaon

     Previous  |  Next  |  Back to Messages Save Message Text 


---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
Exclusive Video Premiere - Britney Spears

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]