Aiming Wand at Bellatrix Lestrange: CRUCIO!

jackson_tm2000 jacksontm at chartermi.net
Mon Sep 1 01:56:23 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 79408

> The fact that he used Crucio! must be important.  It's not 
something 
> she should lightly throw around, especially since she stressed 
that 
> you get a lifetime sentence in Azkaban for trying it.  Was it to 
> show us that he's not like the deatheaters?  or is it to show us 
he 
> reached his breaking point?  


Harry's failure with the Crucio curse does help explain some of 
the "childish" curses used by the DE on Harry and the others at the 
MOM.  If the unforgivable curses require hate/sadism/loathing on the 
part of the user towards the recipient, then it is likely that the 
DE would be ineffective at using these curses against Harry, et al, 
since they really didn't know the kids, and were only there for the 
prophecy(with the exception, perhaps of Lucius and Bellatrix).  Is 
this why Voldemort was more involved with certain killings and left 
others to his DE? (i.e. killing baby Harry)

Tom






More information about the HPforGrownups archive