Harry Potter is a CHILDREN'S BOOK re: rape sexual preference

Mark D. uncmark at yahoo.com
Mon Sep 1 06:20:40 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 79410

I've just read about 20 posts regarding Umbridge's possible rape at 
the hands of centaurs as well as Harry's sexual preference.

EXCUSE ME Harry Potter is a Children's Book!!!
There are plenty of SLASH websites if you wand. I personally feel 
you're giving JKR a great insult by thinking she'd put it in her 
books.

Also I think you have a strange view of the Centaurs. They strike me 
a bound by honor. They will not harm a child and I don't believe 
they would act without full consensus of their tribe (herd, whatever 
they call it).

The Centaurs may very well might have killed Umbridge, but I would 
never believe they'd rape her. That would more repulsive to them 
than Firenze's crime of serving humans. But to kill Umbrige, the 
centaurs would have to agree on one punishment and carry it out.
But they were sort of busy (I'm guessing for most of the night) with 
a angry giant that they had shot with arrows trying to stomp them.

I suppose just being carrried off by a centaur while being chased by 
a giant could emomionally scar anyone.

As for guessing on Harry's sexual preference, again Harry Potter is 
a Children's Book!!!

Also Harry is now only 15. He has never had friends before Hogwarts. 
and there was only one described crush in the Potterverse... Cho. As 
for Harry not understanding girls, what male does?
 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive