Special Qualities of Auror Magic?
Tom Wall
thomasmwall at yahoo.com
Tue Sep 2 23:12:55 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 79591
After rereading the *beginning* of OoP (I've already read and re-
read the end about a bazillion times,) I noticed something odd in
Ch.3, "The Advance Guard:" the only people who use magic at Privet
Drive in this chapter (of which we know) are Tonks and Moody - the
Aurors.
"Why are we all standing in the dark?" said a third voice, this one
completely unfamiliar, a woman's. "Lumos." (OoP, US hardcover, Ch.3,
p47)
"Don't be stupid, it'll be much quicker if I pack!" (ibid, p53)
"That could do with a bit of cleaning, too Scourgify " (ibid, p53)
"Okay, let's go. Locomotor Trunk." (ibid, p53)
In addition, there's Moody's use of the Disillusionment Charm on
Harry (p54), and Moody's unlocking of the back door. (ibid)
Of course, thanks to Tonks, we know that the Aurors
learn "Concealment and Disguise," and "Stealth and Tracking" during
their training. (ibid, p52) Perhaps there is some kind of skill
involved with these classes that make one's very *spells* stealthy.
It seems reasonable to me that this would be a valuable attribute to
possess... since detection in the Aurors' line of work could have
deadly consequences.
But, do you think that they'd be taught how to keep their magic
undetectable even to the Ministry itself?
As we know, use of *any* magic at Harry's house has classically been
detected by the Ministry of Magic first, we have Dobby's use of a
hover charm in CoS, which illustrates that it is not just *wizard*
magic that the Ministry is detecting. Then we have Harry's
accidental blowing up of Aunt Marge in PoA. Finally, in OoP, we have
Harry's use of the Patronus Charm, which results in his Hearing at
the Ministry of Magic. Yet, here is a case where magic is used at
least six times, and we hear nothing to the effect that the Ministry
has detected it.
Arthur also uses magic on Privet Drive in GoF, when the Weasleys are
picking Harry up before the Quidditch World Cup (QWC.) As far as we
know, Harry didn't get another warning in this case, but I'd suggest
that any problems derived from this could be easily explained away
by Arthur himself after all, Fudge personally sees Harry in the
Top Box at the QWC.
One problem I have with this idea, in general, is Mundungus'
Apparation and Disapparation on Privet Drive. I can't figure out why
this wouldn't be detected, nor (since Harry has been under
surveillance all summer) why the possible Apparation and
Disapparation of the *other* members of the Order wasn't detected
either.
Of course, Dumbledore might know how to keep magic from being
detected as well... that man's always full of surprises. ;-)
-Tom
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive