[HPforGrownups] Neville's broken nose

[Erin]

No: HPFGUIDX 79655

At 11:15 AM 9/3/2003, you wrote:

>In the battle scene in OOP, after Neville's nose gets broken and he
>is taunted by Bellatrix about his parents, he screams "I DOE YOU HAB"
>at her.
>
>I have always interpreted this as "I DO YOU HARM", but I recently got
>to thinking about it, and it seems a grammatically and syntactically
>*odd* thing to say.
>
>Are there any other thoughts or interpretations as to what Neville
>meant to say?
>
>- Lana Lovegood
>
>


Erin H.:

I thought Neville said "I know you have." Maybe I'm wrong, but I thought it 
was a very poignant moment in OotP.

Erin883514.jpg 

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]