Neville's broken nose

n_longbottom01 n_longbottom01 at yahoo.com
Wed Sep 3 19:40:05 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 79700

> Talisman, skipping back the other way with a basket of humorous-
> toffees, snorks:
> 
> Well, I DID think of DD's nose, but I was REALLY REALLY kidding 
> about the time turner.
> 
> Talisman, ready to break any freaking time-turner she sees:)

Now me (n_longbottom01):

Ah... good, you were kidding.  I just saw you there weeping openly :) 
about the thought of Neville time-turning into Dumbledore, and I 
thought I would try to provide some comfort.  :)

Be careful how you kid.  :)  You make a joking connection between 
Neville and Dumbledores broken noses, and 500 posts later someone 
comes up with INN BATHROOM or something like that.  If Neville's Nose 
Breaks At least Twice He ... oh this is too hard, how do you guys do 
this?  :)

The idea that Dumbledore is Time-Turned Neville just doesn't click 
for me.  A long while back I read some posts about Ron using a time 
turner to become Dumbledore.  I enjoyed thinking that one through.  I 
think I could see Ron progressing into a wise-old Dumbledore type 
somewhere way down the road.  I'm not saying that it would be 
impossible for Neville to develope into a wise-old Dumbledore type--I 
guess I just have a different picture in my mind of what a grown-up 
Neville might be like.

n_longbottom01 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive