[HPforGrownups] Re: Neville's broken nose

[Kathryn Cawte]

No: HPFGUIDX 79801

*grumble* I know I said this yesterday as well - but please sign messages or
at least attribute your own comments. Sick of having to try and hunt for a
sender name.

Meliss9900 -
 
Actually its far more likely that Albus Dumbledore is just who he says he
is: 
Albus Dumbledore. And his only connection to them is that he's their 
headmaster. 
 
However while we are on this tangent it seems to me that IFsome sort of time

travel is involved then Albus is more Arthur-like in temperment and
interests, 
IMO. 
 
 K -

Well yeah, I don't think any of us seriously believe Albus is a time
travelling version of anyone, even the followers of REDHEAD ALWAYS would
admit it's farfetched and highly unlikely - but it is 'possible' and it's
fun speculating and finding the canon 'evidence' for it. (and yes this is
mainly directed at the person you were responding to rather than you, I
guess). 

But there you go - more evidence for the Ron theory - he acts in an
Arthur-like manner, well I'm sure a mellowed and much older Ron would act
more like his father :)

I love these more lighthearted theories, it makes a nice change from the
intense pro/anti Severus debates and the shipping threads (not that I don't
enjoy those too)

K