Snape and Harry WAS Re: Pensieves objectivity AND: Dumbledore's integrity

[msbeadsley]

No: HPFGUIDX 79839

melclaros: <snip> As to "But he never even told Ron and Hermione what 
he saw, now did he?" No, he didn't. But I'm absolutely SURE he would 
have done if Snape hadn't caught him in the act and thrown his 
tantrum. That scared him into silence.

Nope, not buyin' it.  Harry has told Ron and Hermione so many things 
he trusts them not to discuss with anyone else that I really doubt he 
would hesitate to pass on the scene in the Pensieve just for fear 
that Snape would find out he did.

IMO, Harry will tell them, but only after he's adjusted his image of 
his dad to include one where James could be an arrogant little berk 
at fifteen and a still be a hero of a dad.  We actually see some of 
that when Harry notices Ron has "Quidditch hair."

Sandy, aka "msbeadsley"