Ginny: green eyes or brown eyes?

serenadust jmmears at comcast.net
Fri Sep 5 00:00:06 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 79867

Robyn wrote:
> In CoS, p. 40 (US, paperback), as Harry passes Ginny's room in 
> the Burrow:
 
> "On the third landing, a door stood ajar.  Harry just caught sight 
> of a pair of bright brown eyes staring at him before it closed 
with 
> a snap.  'Ginny'......"
> 
> While listening to CoS on audio tape (Jim Dale's reading), he 
> clearly states "bright green eyes" in this same passage.  If this 
is 
> a mistake, I'm surprised that it would not have been caught and 
> corrected.
> 
> Which is it, brown or green?


I think that Dale goofed and the producers didn't catch it.  Both 
the US and UK versions of CoS say "brown" and in the British cds 
(read by Stephen Fry) it is also "brown". 

I remember when I was new to this list (nearly TWO years ago!), I 
was really thrilled to have caught this and thought I was the first 
one to notice the discrepancy.  Alas, one of the Mods referred me to 
the HPfGU archives where, sure enough she had brought it up way back 
in 2000 *sigh*.  

Jo Serenadust, failed LOON





More information about the HPforGrownups archive