Harry's Grandparents

Tricia Hemans hardcoreukuk at yahoo.co.uk
Fri Sep 5 15:32:39 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 79951

Sarah ("mochajava13") wrote:
> Petunia definitely seemed jealous of Lily, but she also seemed to 
> dislike her too much for the dislike to be mere sibling jealousy(snip)

Now me:
I think that it could be just jealousy. Look at Snape for example: he 
was jealous of James and he's taking it out on Harry. As an adult he 
should have been able to get over it, but he hasn't.

Sarah:
> If they were still alive, someone in the magical community would have 
> mentioned it to Harry by now.  To not tell him that his grandparents 
> were alive would be unnecessarily cruel. (snip)


Now me: Up until book 3 Harry never knew he had a godfather. Who's to 
say they ain't keeping it from him because they could have been into 
Dark Arts. Maybe that's why James dislikes it so much, because he grew 
up with it around him. (Just an idea.) 

"Tricia Hemans"





More information about the HPforGrownups archive