[HPforGrownups] Re: Turncoat!Tonks (was: Aurors/Unforgiveable Curses)

Carolina silmariel at telefonica.net
Sat Sep 6 10:58:23 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 80007


> --RTJ:
<< As it stands, Sirius's nearest blood relatives are the Malfoys, 
the Tonkses, and Bellatrix Lestrange (ugh!). I think that even if 
he doesn't have a will, the house will go to Harry--after all, not> 
only is he Sirius's godson and wizard guardian, Harry once saved
his life, which indicates a deeper attachment.>>

But deep attachments don't have much to say if there is not a will,
why would Harry inherit G.Place if there isn't a last will? When was 
Sirius made legal tutor for Harry? Aren't the Durdsleys his tutors?

I'm thinking on the kind of wills from Authors as Austen, Bronte or 
Eliot. 

Are we sure Sirius could decide what to do of Grimmauld? The Blacks 
could have add a clause stating specifically a condition for 
inheritance: that the family properties would remain in the family, 
here Bellatrix and Narcissa, or Andromeda if she has not been 
specifically excluded, wich I doubt. 

He may have the granted right to use the house as only propietary 
while he lived, I know Sirius states the house is his, but I know a 
case like this and the user of the house instists the house is his, 
and you have to be very close to the family to know it isn't. 

silmariel




More information about the HPforGrownups archive