Book 6 Predictions (was: Predictions at Madison Square Garden)

[hickengruendler]

No: HPFGUIDX 80048

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "mochajava13" 
<mochajava13 at y...> wrote:
 
> 
> Sarah:
> I actually just pegged Ginny for death because the boggart didn't 
> appear as dead Ginny to Molly.
>  The boggart impersonated all the 
> other Weasleys and Harry, but not Ginny. 

It didn't impersonate Charlie, too (or at least, not while Harry was 
around). But I sort of agree with you. My first thought was, that 
Ginny and Charlie might be the Weasleys, who get offed, just because 
they didn't appear as shapes of the boggart. On the other hand, it 
really is no proof.

>  I wasn't trying to suggest that JKR would 
> insinuate that lying Ginny is bad by killing Ginny off.  I just 
> thought that it would be an in-character way to off Ginny.

I agree. But every single character has a treat, that might put them 
in grave danger (like Sirius' recklessness). Percy's wish for power 
and the twins carelessness and irresponsibility, for example, could 
also put them in danger. And Ron has sort of the mixture of 
the "faults" of hid parents.

>  But if 
> we're going for a JKR's-already-put-the-character-in-mortal-peril 
> type thing, than Ron, Ginny, Hermione, and Harry are safe from 
> getting killed off by JKR.  
> Sarah

This argument doesn't count. Sirius was in mortal danger in POA, and 
he died in OOTP.  

Hickengruendler