Questions about year 6; rock'n'roll star Stubby Black

[barbara_mbowen]

No: HPFGUIDX 80142

Udder+pen_Dragon wrote:

,Snape can not be a Werewolf as in POA he is out in the full 
moon coming back
from the shrieking shack with Lupin etc.

Sorry.>

Details, details!  ;>)  Oh well, I knew there had to be a reason it 
wasn't as hot a topic as Snape as vampire.

Still think Stubby Boardman is Regulus Black:.  think of it!  Poor 
little Reggie is no where near as strong willed as his big brother, 
so he's afraid to cross Mom and Dad Black.  But he wants to b
e a rock'n'roll star...it's the only thing he wants....<g>....But he 
can't be a star in the WW, Mommy Dearest would find out.  So, 
he has to set up as a rock musician in the Muggle world.  He's 
so bad, he gets vegetables thrown at him.

 To please Mommy, he's also a DE.  But a bad one. ( Maybe he 
even wears his DE outfit onstage!)  He was supposedly killed 
fifteen years ago, so Sirius says in OoP.  That's just when 
Voldemort attacked the Potters and just when Stubby Boardman 
had to retire from the stage.  Maybe Reg wasn't killed, first 
because there were so many more important killings going on, 
then because Voldemort was cut down by his own AK curse.  
And Reg slipped between the cracks.  He's been hiding out ever 
since.

But of course he looks so very much like Sirius.   This would 
feed into JKR's theme of people treating other people as if they 
were someone else (some one dead else):  Sirius thinking of 
Harry as James; Snape thinking of Harry as James; now Harry 
thinking of Reg as Sirius.  A sad theme.   Harry would insist on 
trusting Reg against other peoples' advise.  Only Crookshanks 
would know for sure....

Just a thought....

Marmelade's Mom