The Marauders Theory(Remus, Sirius, Peter, James)

[furkin1712 at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 80150

Sarah:
>>Harry, like Lupin, has few close friends.  Perhaps this will 
bring Harry and Lupin closer together in more of a father-son 
type relationship.  I for one would love to see that.  They've 
shared the same loses, that of James and Sirius, because of 
Wormtail. (snip) <<

Blue Eyes:
I think that the relationship should've been closer but it seems 
distant, really more distant than it should under the circumstances 
and it seems like it's mostly Remus that's doing that. I think the 
theory about James and Remus switching souls or what not might be 
possible, it's something JKR would do. But I also think that they 
are just suspiciously parted when you are so right and they 
should be closer together.

RTJ:
>>Remus doesn't have supremacy over the Godfather. Quite the opposite 
-- Remus, though the most fair-minded and kindest of the Mauraders, 
has a courage problem and often doesn't stand up to his friends when 
he knows they are wrong. Lately that's changed. When Lupin restrains 
Sirius, he's showing a new streak of courage, besides a determination 
to "fix" the wrongs he did as a younger man. <<

Blue Eyes:
Still doesn't answer why he would take a decision from Sirius that 
is legally his. I mean, in all sense Sirius was Harry's replacement 
father, now why would that have to be restrained by Remus. I mean I get 
that Sirius would've done something rash, but that phrase bothers me. I 
mean, think on it. It's just odd that it's phrased like that, I mean he 
could've said Calm down and think striaght Sirius a different way.

Sandy: 
(snip)
>> but Lupin wrenched him back down again.
  "If anyone's going to tell Snape it will be me!" <<

Blue Eyes:
I know that he's trying not to get him killed but I'm just thinking 
that it's odd he phrased it like that, I mean technically it is Sirius' 
right to protect Harry and such, but why would Remus say "...it will 
be me!" 

Just makes me wonder on the theory of the Soul Switching. Just something 
thats been tickling me oddly.

*-Blue Eyes-*