CoS scene.

laylalast liliana at worldonline.nl
Tue Sep 9 19:31:02 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 80268

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, B Arrowsmith 
<arrowsmithbt at b...> wrote:
> Sitting  gazing vacantly at the ceiling as usual when I remembered 
an 
> anomaly.
> 
> There was speculation a few weeks ago as posters tried to figure 
out 
> which episode in CoS  had been retained in the CoS film at the 
> insistence of JKR.
> 
> In the book, we have the meeting between Harry and Dumbledore in 
DD's 
> office after the petrification of Justin Finch-Fletchley and Nearly 
> Headless Nick. Hagrid  bursts in carrying a couple of dead 
roosters, 
> proclaiming Harry is innocent. Now we know about Ginny killing the 
> roosters and why she has done it. But this is not explained in the 
film.
> 
> So why does Hagrid still barge in carrying two dead (apparently 
> irrelevant) roosters?
> 
> Can anyone think of a plot line for the future books that needs 
Hagrid 
> and two dead chickens?
> Or perhaps just the chickens. Haruspicy? A  magical stock-pot? 
> Son-of-Trevor? Fowl play?
> 
> Any ideas out there?
> 
> Kneasy

Lilian here:

The scene with the roosters (it is only one rooster actually, Hagrid 
says that is the second one recently dead) is not  in the movie 
itself but is in the additional scenes on the DVD. People who have 
only seen the movie, do not get to see Hagrid with the roosters. To 
me that is the reason why the dead rooster-scene need not be 
explained in the movie, because it never made the movie at all.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive